Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Meditations 6: more on what nature teaches us...

In the first half of part 6 of Meditations, Descartes uses nature as an excuse for the pairing of a particular mind with a particular body despite his claims that the two are separate. It turns out that Descartes goes on to discuss how nature teaches us many things, some of which are true and others false. He makes a point that anything which we seem to know naturally is implanted in us by God. Descartes tries to make a distinction between nature's true and false teachings. He says that there are three subsets of natural teachings. The first pertains only to the mind; the second pertains only to the body; the third pertains to the relation between the mind and body.  The first subset, according to Descartes, is always true. Things pertaining only to the mind are clear and distinct concepts that must be true. Descartes is not concerned with the second subset, and he claims that the truth of the contents of the third subset varies. He claims that false natural teachings regarding the relation between mind and body are mere misinterpretations. So although it is true that something in heat excites pain, there is nothing that resembles pain inside the heat. Descartes claims that the problem is that we have conflicting signals about what to do or not do, and this can be blamed on our bodies. He says that there are two main sources of error that are a direct result of the body:  (1) the mind and body are distinct; the mind is unified and the body is divisible... (2) some bodily feelings are exaggerated or misdirected, making them deceptive. 

Meditations 6: A problem with dualism

In part 6 of Meditations, Descartes talks more about dualism and the distinction between mind and body. He talks about how he knows that the mind exists ("I think therefore I am"), but he has to work through an argument to prove that the body exists (Matt talks about that in his first post on this section).  Once Descartes is satisfied that both the mind and the body exist, he has to work out a way to justify the connection his soul has with his particular body. This is a problem because if all minds are distinct from all bodies, then there is no way to account for things like hunger, thirst, pleasure, and pain. If my mind is independent from my body, like Descartes suggests, that why does my mind only recognize pain that is inflicted upon my body? What accounts for the joining of a mind with a body? Further, if every living body is paired with a soul, are the two really distinct? Descartes questions this...

"As for the body which by some special right I called 'mine,' my belief that this body, more than any other, belonged to me had some justification. For I could never be separated from it, as I could from other bodies; and I felt all my appetites and emotions in, and on account of, this body; and finally, I was aware of pain and pleasurable ticklings in parts of this body, but not in other bodies external to it. But why should that curious sensation of pain give rise to a particular distress of mind; or why should a certain kind of delight follow on a tickling sensation? Again, why should that curious tugging in the stomach which I call hunger tell me that I should eat, or a dryness of the throat tell me to drink, and so on? I was not able to give any explanation of all this, except that nature taught me so. For there is absolutely no connection (at least that I can understand) between the tugging sensation and the decision to take food..."

"Nature taught me so" is the best explanation I can find for Descartes' response to this problem. He goes on from this section of part 6 to talk about the mind-body distinction in a very matter-of-fact way. He says that he knows himself to be a thinking thing that does not exist in space, and he has "a distinct idea of body, in so far s this is simply an extended, non-thinking thing." He comes to the conclusion that he is distinct from his body and that he can exist without it. 

I'm not convinced. 

Monday, February 11, 2008

Meditation 6

In chapter 6 of the meditations Descartes uses this chapter to talk about the real distinction between the mind and the body and the existence of material things. He starts out this part by stating that material things can exist because God is able to make them exist. He goes into talking about how since he can clearly grasp something (pure mathematics) they must therefore exist. Knowing the existence of such objects is possible and he goes into trying to prove this by using the idea of mental images. He does this by drawing a distinction between mental images and understanding. Descartes uses an example to further this point.
“When I have a mental image of a triangle, for example, I don't just understand that it is a figure bounded by three lines; I also "look at" the lines as though they were present to my mind's eye. And this is what I call having a mental image. When I want to think of a chiliagon, I understand that it is a figure with a thousand sides as well as I understand that a triangle is a figure with three, but I can't imagine its sides or "look" at them as though they were present.”

I rather agree with Descartes on this idea of distinction between mental images and understanding. There is definitely I difference between the two ideas and I sort of have a example of this. I can imagine a unicorn that it is a horse that has a horn like a rhino or some other animal with a horn. Though I can imagine this animal because it is made up of other animals I can not truly understand what a unicorn is until I could see one for myself which is impossible.

meditation 6

Meditation six deals with the existence and material things but what really interests me is Descartes idea of the proof for the body being separate and distinct from the soul. His proof goes like this, What ever god can create I can perceive it, if got creates things to be separate from one another, they are distinct from each other, I understand my existence therefore I don’t need a body, so god can make a thinking thing independent of a body, so my soul is distinct from my body. So I can exist without a body. I find his proof very interesting, just wonder how he came to some of the conclusions about his proof. One of my biggest problems is that god can make a soul distinct from the body but how does he get his soul is distinct from the body. How does he know that God doesn’t choose or only certain people have souls distinct from their bodies?

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Meditation 5- The ontological argument

". . .when I concentrate more carefully, it is quite evident that existence can no more be separated from the essence of God than the fact that its three angles equal two right angles can be separated from the essence of a triangle, or than the idea of a mountain can be separated from the idea of a valley."
Descartes reasons that he cannot think of God as not existing, so he must exist. Now this seems pretty foolish. Here is his reason: it is the essence of God to exist, just as it is impossible to imagine a triangle without it having three angles equaling 180 degrees, and impossible to think of a mountain which doesn't have a corresponding valley. Here essence can be separated from existence: just because we cannot separate the idea of a mountain from a valley doesn't mean that either one necessarily exists- it just means that IF a mountain exists then it must have a corresponding valley. For Descartes though, it is part of the essence of God to exist, so that God is the only being in which existence is included in or implied by his essence. Descartes says that this is because God is perfect, and existence is a perfection, just as omniscience and omnipotence are. So this sounds a little bit better than it did in the beginning.

So here is Descartes' version of he ontological argument:

1. God is perfect
2. It is part of the essence of something perfect to exist
C: God exists

I'm sure that this argument seems wrong in some way, whether or not you can put your finger on what seems wrong about it. Here is what is wrong: existence is not a predicate (or a property attributable to something). Of course anything which has a property exists, but existence itself is not a property, it is a quantifier ( as Immanuel Kant will later point out).

Friday, February 8, 2008

Part 5 of Meditation

In part 5 of meditation, Descartes compares God's existence to the existence of a triangle. He says that he did not use his senses to know the nature of a triangle. He claims he can think of all types of shapes that he's never seen before, but can still know the properties of those shapes. He says that he's always regarded mathematical and geometrical objects to be more certain than objects of the senses. He goes on to talk about the essence of objects and says that the essence of a triangle is the fact that it has 3 sides so if an object did not have 3 sides, it would be impossible for it to be a triangle. Since the triangle is such a clear and distinct idea, then it must exist. He continues and says that since God is also such a clear and distinct idea and the essence of God is existence, he must exist.

I agree with Descartes here a little, I think it is possible to think of different shapes and draw visualizations of those shapes from the idea of them, but I don't think just because God's is a clear and distinct idea in Descartes' mind, it means that he must exist. It just seems like there can be a lot of things that may seem like a clear and distinct idea in your head and turn out to be completely false.

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Discourse, Part 5: Immortal Soul

Descartes talks about the rational soul in part five of the Discourse. He discusses the human form as a separate entity that does not necessarily require the rational soul in order to operate.  Descartes claims that God did not initially pair his design of the human body with a rational soul, but rather with animal spirits.  The idea that the human body can exist with or without the rational soul implies that the soul is completely distinct from the body. Descartes claims that the human soul is powerful enough to exist independently of the body (something that animal spirits can’t do), and therefore it is able to survive when the body dies. While disease and aging wear down the human body and eventually destroy it, the human soul is immune to these and all other forces. This makes the soul immortal.